By Jennifer Schaefer, MBA, ChFC, CLU, RHU, REBC, SHRM-SCP
Founder & CEO, JS Benefits Group | Forbes Business Council Contributor | Co-Host of Executive Leaders Radio
When business owners review their expenses, they usually pay close attention to payroll, rent, marketing, and operating costs. But one significant expense can receive less scrutiny than it deserves: employee healthcare.
For small and midsize businesses, health insurance can represent a substantial financial commitment. Employers want to provide competitive benefits, but rising costs can put pressure on cash flow, limit hiring budgets, and reduce the money available for expansion.
After more than three decades in the employee benefits industry, I have seen businesses approach healthcare renewals as if the annual increase were simply unavoidable. In reality, employers can take steps to better understand their spending and evaluate whether their current plans still make financial sense.
The key is to treat healthcare as a business expense that deserves the same attention as any other major financial commitment.
1. Understand the True Cost of Employee Healthcare
The monthly insurance premium is only one part of the financial picture.
Depending on the plan, employers may also face administrative expenses, contributions toward health savings accounts, stop-loss premiums, and other costs associated with providing coverage.
Employees also experience costs through deductibles, copayments, coinsurance, and prescription expenses. Although these amounts are not necessarily direct employer expenses, they influence the overall value of the benefits package and the financial well-being of the workforce.
Business owners should examine the total cost of their benefits program rather than focusing exclusively on the premium.
Questions worth asking include:
- How much does the company contribute toward employee and dependent coverage?
- How have healthcare expenses changed over the past several years?
- Which factors are driving the latest renewal increase?
- Are employees facing significant out-of-pocket expenses?
- Does the existing plan remain competitive with available alternatives?
A clearer understanding of these costs can help employers make more informed financial decisions.
2. Stop Treating the Annual Renewal as a Routine Exercise
Many businesses follow a familiar pattern. Their insurance renewal arrives, the proposed increase is reviewed, and the company decides whether to accept it or change plans.
The problem is that a renewal percentage does not necessarily explain why costs are increasing.
Medical claims, prescription drug spending, provider pricing, and plan design can all influence healthcare expenses. Different employers may experience different cost pressures, even when their renewal increases appear similar.
Employers should ask their benefits advisors to explain the factors behind the increase and identify areas that warrant further investigation.
Starting the review well before renewal gives a company more time to evaluate options, compare proposals, and assess potential trade-offs.
This process should also examine whether the existing plan continues to meet the company’s needs. A policy that worked well several years ago may no longer be the most appropriate choice as the business grows or its workforce changes.
3. Examine Prescription Drug Spending
Prescription drug expenses deserve particular attention when evaluating a health plan.
Specialty medications and expensive therapies can contribute substantially to healthcare spending. At the same time, pharmacy benefit arrangements can be complicated, making it difficult for employers to understand the financial details.
Employers should review the available pharmacy reporting and ask questions about their pharmacy benefit manager contracts.
Areas to examine include formulary arrangements, specialty drug spending, administrative fees, rebates, and the overall net cost of prescription coverage.
The objective is to understand what the company is paying and whether its current arrangements provide appropriate value.
Cost management must also account for employee health. Decisions about prescription coverage should consider clinical appropriateness and access to necessary medications, not just the lowest available price.
4. Evaluate Alternative Health Plan Funding Arrangements
One of the most important financial decisions an employer makes is how to fund its health insurance plan.
Fully insured plans generally provide a defined premium structure during the policy period. Self-funded plans place more direct responsibility for claims costs on the employer, typically with third-party administration and stop-loss protection. Level-funded arrangements combine fixed monthly payments with claims-related financial considerations, depending on the contract.
For some employers, evaluating level-funded health plans may be worthwhile.
These arrangements can offer an alternative to traditional fully insured coverage, but they are not appropriate for every business. Employers must understand the contract, stop-loss provisions, claims assumptions, potential liabilities, and circumstances under which additional payments could be required.
The lowest initial monthly payment does not automatically represent the lowest total cost.
A responsible comparison should consider expected expenses, potential variability, contractual obligations, and the financial consequences of different claims scenarios.
Employers should also understand how any claims surplus or deficit is handled under the specific agreement.
The goal is to select a funding arrangement that fits the company’s financial position and tolerance for risk.
5. Protect Cash Flow Without Undermining Employee Benefits
When healthcare costs increase, business owners may consider shifting more of the expense to employees.
Although changing employee contributions or deductibles can affect the employer’s budget, these decisions should not be made in isolation.
Higher employee costs can make coverage less affordable and reduce the perceived value of the benefits package. That can create challenges for businesses competing to attract and retain employees.
Instead, employers should evaluate the entire plan.
Could a different plan design offer a better balance between premiums and out-of-pocket costs? Are employees enrolled in options that fit their circumstances? Is the company communicating its benefits effectively? Are there opportunities to improve the way the plan is administered?
These questions can help employers explore alternatives without assuming that cost reductions must come entirely from employees.
A thoughtful employee benefits strategy can help a business evaluate its coverage, budget, and workforce needs together.
The objective is to find a sustainable balance between financial responsibility and meaningful employee benefits.
6. Use Data to Make Better Financial Decisions
Business owners would rarely make a major investment without reviewing the numbers. Healthcare spending should receive similar attention.
Depending on the plan and available reporting, employers may be able to review claims trends, pharmacy expenses, enrollment changes, and other indicators that help explain performance.
This information can support better conversations about the company’s healthcare costs.
For example, a business experiencing rising prescription expenses may need to investigate its pharmacy arrangements. Another employer may need to examine whether its plan design or funding arrangement remains appropriate.
The response should reflect the actual circumstances rather than a generic cost-cutting formula.
Employers should also remember that past claims do not guarantee future results. Healthcare spending can be unpredictable, and projections should be treated as estimates rather than promises.
Data is most useful when it helps decision-makers ask better questions and evaluate alternatives.
7. Make Healthcare Cost Management an Ongoing Responsibility
Healthcare planning should not begin and end with the annual renewal.
Businesses can benefit from establishing a regular schedule for reviewing available reports, discussing cost trends, and evaluating the performance of their benefits arrangements.
A review might include:
- Changes in total healthcare spending.
- Medical and prescription drug cost trends.
- Employee contributions and out-of-pocket expenses.
- Plan performance relative to budget expectations.
- Contract terms and administrative costs.
- Opportunities to improve plan design or benefits communication.
The appropriate frequency depends on the company’s size, funding arrangement, and access to information.
Employers should also establish clear responsibilities for reviewing the results and deciding which issues require further investigation.
This approach can help prevent healthcare spending from becoming an annual surprise and give the business more time to evaluate its options.
Healthcare Spending Is a Financial Strategy Issue
Employee healthcare is not simply an insurance decision. It is part of a company’s broader financial strategy.
Rising costs can affect cash flow, compensation budgets, hiring decisions, and profitability. Yet cutting benefits without understanding the underlying issues can create problems of its own.
Employers need to understand their spending, evaluate their contracts, and compare appropriate alternatives before deciding what changes to make.
There is no universal solution. The right approach depends on the company’s workforce, financial circumstances, current coverage, and tolerance for risk.
But one principle applies to nearly every business: a major recurring expense deserves ongoing attention.
By examining healthcare costs throughout the year, employers can make more informed decisions, prepare for renewal discussions, and work toward providing meaningful benefits in a financially sustainable way.
About Jennifer Schaefer
Jennifer Schaefer, MBA, ChFC, CLU, RHU, REBC, SHRM-SCP, is the Founder and CEO of JS Benefits Group, an employee benefits consulting firm serving employers across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, New York, and beyond. She is a Forbes Business Council Contributor and Co-Host of Executive Leaders Radio. With more than three decades of industry experience, Jennifer advises employers on healthcare cost management, health plan design, and employee benefits strategy.





Leave a Reply